Heritage

Do Hispanics lack tact or are Americans too politically correct?

Read related: Stereotypes die hard, if ever

Back in 1993 I was convinced that there was a secret conspiracy against me. The operatives? Venezuelan teenage girls.

“You look great, but have you put on a couple pounds?” one whispered to me at a fiesta de quinceañera. “That’s a beautiful dress but, how are you going to hide your barriga in it?” another girl asked about my teenage body that couldn’t have weighed more than 110 lbs.

I really thought they hated me and that their secret mission was to rob me of all self-confidence. But then I noticed that they made similar comments to each other, and apparently it was not considered insulting or rude.

"I was convinced that there was a secret conspiracy against me"

Several years later while in grad school in Madrid, there was a new conspiracy, but this time the operatives were Spanish women criticizing my haircut.

“You really shouldn’t have bangs at your age,” one lady said to me.

I was unaware of an age cutoff for bangs, but in her opinion, 29 was too old. (Ironically about a year later, bangs became all the rage in Madrid). On another occasion, when I told a teacher I wouldn’t be able to make it to class because I was sick, rather than get-well wishes, her response was, “Well, it’s your loss.”

 Readjusting my outlook

With a bit more maturity under my belt, I considered the possibility that these comments may not be personal and I decided to stop internalizing them. I even wondered if this frankness was a sign of confianza. Maybe I was close enough that they felt they could tell me these things, like sisters. It was a compliment! Ok, that was probably a bit of a stretch, but it was my way of keeping an open mind about it.

Are American overly sensitive?

According to the director of my graduate program in Spain, who was madrileña through and through, “Americans are overly sensitive.”

One summer, when I was working as her office assistant, she asked me to write a response to an American student who had been denied a scholarship.

“I would just tell him that it was because his essay wasn’t that impressive and that his grades weren’t good enough, but I can’t tell him that,” she explained.

Being that she worked at an American university in Spain, she had to follow American protocol. And so she asked me to draft up a letter with all the tiptoeing, beating around the bush, and ambiguous yada yada yada that we Americans are apparently so good at.

The verdict

Are Americans overly sensitive? Are Hispanics less tactful? Or is it just a difference in social norms? Let’s face it, for as much as we try to avoid generalizations in our über-PC society, cultural customs vary from country to country. Travel books have entire chapters dedicated to them.

Even so, the question of tact can’t be addressed without considering the subject of conversation. For example, at Elvira Lindo‘s recent book presentation at the Instituto Cervantes in New York, she talked about how Americans speak about salaries and money much more openly than Spaniards.

Does that make Americans tactless when it comes to money? Are Spaniards and Latin Americans rude when it comes to commenting on physical appearance? Or is it all relative?

From a young age, we are taught what is rude and what is polite, but those are internal settings specific to the societies in which we were raised, and they may require some readjusting when we leave our home culture.

I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s best to not judge people of foreign customs according to our own social norms, which in all likelihood are foreign to them.

Read related: How to leave a Latino party gracefully

You may follow Crystal Honores on Twitter.

email

About Crystal Honores

Crystal Honores is a New York-based writer and editor. She is Senior Editor at Meredith Corporation's Hispanic Ventures division and the Guide for Literatura at About.com of The New York Times Company. She has a Master of Arts in Spanish literature from Saint Louis University's Madrid campus. She firmly believes that poetry can cure most ailments of the human race and that a stanza a day would make the world a better place.
Heritage

Related Stories

  • http://voxxi.com/2011/12/11/diary-of-a-teacher-mom/ Eileen Carter-Campos

    Crystal,

    Very sensitive topic and you tackled it well. People have their own beliefs, customs, etc…
    I just IGNORE & keep it moving! lol

    Thanks!!!

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=625105781 Crystal Honores

      Thank you, Eileen!

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001170293412 eileencarter-campos

        :)

  • http://voxxi.com/category/mujer/dating-mujer/ Paloma Corredor

    I love it, Crystal!! This subject fascinates me too.

    The first time I was in NY I was impressed by how kind people was. Specially at Starbucks, that didn´t exist in Spain yet!! Then, as days went by I began thinking it was all on the surface. I mean, they were just being polite.

    Same thing happened when I was living in London. Specially at work. Everything was “Would you please…”, “Lovely!”, “Great job!”. Sometimes I wished they would shout at me and tell me what they were really thinking.

    So yes, I missed spontaneity, to be honest. But I really like the, let´s say, protocol of kidness. Being polite and positive is smart, it allows you to say anything you want. That´s what I´ve learned from Anglos and it´s been very useful for me.

    I hate the way Spanish focus on the negative things and don´t hesitate to be rude and complain about everything. But at the same time I appreciate the passion, the vehemence… as long as it´s not offensive.

    Well, if we could find a “happy medium” it would be great. I remember one day at the office in London and this German lady talking about another colleague who was sitting somewhere else in the room, but I was new and didn´t know who this person was. Being Spanish, I would have pointed at her or would have said “the black lady”. Would that be offensive? Not for me, considering that she was the only black lady around. But I have to confess I would have been also tempted to say “The black FAT lady”. That´s the Spanish way. So would “fat” be offensive? Well, it depends too, don´t you think so?

    This is an endless and fascinating topic…!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=625105781 Crystal Honores

    Thanks, Paloma! What I always wonder about is if other Spaniards on the receiving end of these negative comments find it offensive? In your case, because you’ve lived abroad, you see things with a new perspective. But what about Spaniards (or Latin Americans for that matter) that have never known any other way of being. Is this somehow less offensive to them? Oh, and btw, if you think New Yorkers are nice, you should make a visit to the South!

  • Paloma Corredor

    Well, I´m lucky to be surrounded by very nice people, including South American friends that are not like that. But one day I realized that my mother´s family is exactly like that. Always talking about the bad things: if someone looks older, fat, disgusting… I remember my aunts with the TV on just to say things like “Oh look at that bitch”, “I can´t stand that woman” and so on… I said, “Why don´t you just turn off the tv?” but they didn´t even listen to me. When the whole family (10 brothers plus husbands, wifes etc) are together they talk a lot, but always screaming and talking about other people and politics… always negative.

    I guess they don´t find it offensive, it´s the way they´re used to behave. But I do and try to avoid that people.

    Dios los cría y ellos se juntan!!

  • Veronique de Miguel

    Loved it, a delightful picture of both cultures!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/6IZMQFKMFAOAZH7Q2HZZLHABNE Bolo

    First time here, and  I love your post.    Looking forward to reading more. And may you have many blessings  in your life’s journey.

    Sinceramented un  amigo

    Jose  Carlos